免责声明:本网站不构成法律建议。法律法规和判例法会发生变化。请务必就您的具体情况咨询合格的律师。

所有案例
Unjust Enrichment
House of Lords
1999

Kleinwort Benson Ltd v Lincoln City Council

[1999] 2 AC 349

判决理由

Money paid under a mistake of law is recoverable in a claim for restitution, just as money paid under a mistake of fact. The old rule barring recovery for mistakes of law was abolished.

事实

Banks entered into interest rate swap agreements with local authorities. After the agreements were held to be void (following Hazell v Hammersmith), the banks sought to recover money paid under them.

判决摘要

The House of Lords (3–2) held that the mistake of law bar should be abolished. Money paid under a mistake of law is recoverable in restitution on the same basis as money paid under a mistake of fact.

关键引述

"I can see no good reason for the mistake of law rule to be maintained in our law."

Lord Goff

后续处理

Foundational

Abolished the mistake of law rule; fundamental to the modern law of unjust enrichment.